Customer Loyalty Trends for 2025: What Growing DTC Brands Need to Know

As we step into 2025, customer loyalty continues to evolve in response to shifting consumer behaviors, technological advancements, and increasing competition. For growing direct-to-consumer (DTC) brands, building and maintaining customer loyalty is not just an opportunity—it’s a necessity.

Key Loyalty Trends Shaping 2025

Sephora’s Beauty Insider loyalty program offers personalized product recommendations, exclusive promotions, and tailored beauty workshops based on members' past purchases and preferences.

Nike leverages its app ecosystem to deliver workout tips, gear suggestions, and rewards personalized to the user’s fitness goals and purchase history.

2. Sustainability and Values-Driven Loyalty
Modern consumers align their loyalty with brands that share their values, particularly sustainability and social responsibility.

Brand's Who Do It Well:

Patagonia’s loyalty initiatives encourage customers to repair rather than replace their gear, promoting sustainability. Customers are rewarded with points for engaging in eco-friendly behaviors, such as attending events or participating in environmental activism.

H&M’s Conscious Points program rewards customers for recycling clothing in-store, aligning with the brand’s sustainability commitment.

3. Gamification and Tiered Rewards
Gamification adds an element of fun and competition to loyalty programs, while tiered systems encourage ongoing engagement and spending.

Brand's Who Do It Well:

Starbucks’ Rewards program uses gamification by awarding stars for purchases, which customers can redeem for free items. Seasonal challenges and bonus star promotions keep members engaged.

Marriott Bonvoy’s tiered loyalty program incentivizes frequent travelers with escalating benefits, from complimentary upgrades to exclusive member-only experiences, creating a sense of achievement for loyal members.

4. Data-Driven Insights for Loyalty Optimization

Brands are increasingly relying on data to understand customer preferences and improve their loyalty programs.

Brand's Who Do It Well:

Example: Amazon Prime uses customer purchase and browsing data to recommend products and deliver curated promotions. The program is designed to deepen loyalty by making shopping faster, easier, and more personalized.

Example: Ulta Beauty’s Ultimate Rewards program collects detailed purchase data to create personalized experiences and exclusive promotions, ensuring members feel valued and understood.

5. Always-On Engagement
Loyalty programs are becoming less about transactions and more about maintaining continuous, meaningful interactions.

Brand's Who Do It Well:

Peloton offers members year-round engagement through exclusive classes, community challenges, and access to instructor-curated playlists. Their loyalty strategy focuses on community building rather than direct incentives.

Apple’s ecosystem encourages loyalty by creating a seamless, interconnected experience across devices and services, supported by year-round software updates, personalized app recommendations, and exclusive content like Apple Music playlists.

Where Growing DTC Brands Should Start

For brands looking to scale, loyalty programs must be strategic, measurable, and aligned with business goals. This is where Baesman Group can help.

Through our comprehensive Loyalty Audit, we take a deep dive into your current program or help design one from scratch. Our four-phased approach includes:

• Defining Goals and Success Metrics: Align your loyalty program with overarching business objectives.
• Customer and Competitive Analysis: Understand your audience and how your program stacks up in the industry.
• Scorecard Evaluation: Measure performance across key metrics and identify areas of improvement.
• Tailored Program Design: Build a flexible, engaging, and financially sound loyalty strategy.

Case Study: Shoe Carnival’s Loyalty Transformation

Shoe Carnival, one of the nation’s largest footwear chains with over 370 stores, exemplifies how a strategic loyalty program revamp can deliver incredible results.

The Challenge: Shoe Carnival’s loyalty program, Shoe Perks, had significant untapped potential with just over 400,000 members. They needed a solution to grow membership, increase engagement, and improve per-member value.

The Solution: Baesman redesigned the loyalty program from the ground up, addressing database functionality, member experience, and communication strategies. By synchronizing the program across all purchasing channels, analyzing member behavior, and establishing success metrics, Baesman transformed Shoe Perks into a powerhouse loyalty program.

The Results:

• Membership Growth: From 400,000 to over 6.5 million members in just three years.
• Increased Spend: Shoe Perks members spent 30% more than non-members.
• Engagement Spike: In just one year, the email list grew by 273%, and active buyers surged by 138%.

Insights for 2025 Success

For growing DTC brands, loyalty is about more than just retention—it’s about building advocacy and long-term relationships. Brands with successful loyalty programs in 2025 are setting themselves apart by embracing the following practices:

1. Prioritizing Personalization at Scale

Personalization has moved beyond addressing customers by name in emails. Leading brands are leveraging first-party data to deliver hyper-relevant experiences. This includes:

• Curating product recommendations based on past purchases or browsing behavior by understanding the customer journey.
• Offering dynamic rewards that align with individual customer preferences.
• Sending timely reminders or incentives tied to personal milestones, such as birthdays or anniversaries.

For instance, a growing skincare brand might use purchase history to recommend replenishments or complementary products, creating a seamless, helpful shopping experience.

2. Aligning Loyalty Programs with Brand Values

Successful brands understand that loyalty extends beyond transactions—it’s about emotional connection. Programs tied to social or environmental causes resonate with value-driven consumers. Examples include:

• Rewarding customers for sustainable behaviors, such as recycling old products or choosing eco-friendly shipping options.
• Partnering with charitable organizations and allowing members to donate points to causes they care about.

This approach not only attracts but also retains customers who feel good about aligning with the brand’s mission.

3. Incorporating Gamification

Gamification strategies are boosting engagement and creating stickiness in loyalty programs. Some effective tactics include:

• Progress Bars and Challenges: Showing how close a customer is to earning a reward or moving up a tier.
• Surprise-and-Delight Moments: Reward loyal members with bonus points or exclusive perks to foster excitement.
• Interactive Campaigns: Encouraging members to participate in quizzes, polls, or games to earn rewards.

Brands that incorporate these elements create a sense of fun and achievement, which keeps customers coming back.

4. Building Omnichannel Loyalty Experiences

The most successful loyalty programs work seamlessly across all touchpoints, whether in-store, online, or through mobile apps. Key strategies include:

• Offering unified rewards that customers can redeem regardless of how they shop.
• Integrating loyalty features into mobile apps, such as digital membership cards, instant points tracking, and personalized offers.
• Geofencing or app notifications can be used to provide localized rewards or incentives for in-store visits.

Shoe Carnival’s success story is a prime example—integrating their loyalty program across channels led to significant membership and engagement growth​.

5. Focusing on “Always-On” Engagement

Successful programs don’t rely on one-off campaigns to drive loyalty. Instead, they maintain continuous, meaningful interactions with members. Examples include:

• Sending regular, value-driven communications like tips, product education, or exclusive content.
• Offering year-round benefits, such as free shipping or early access to new collections, to keep members engaged even when they’re not making purchases.
• Using dynamic triggers, such as abandoned cart reminders or loyalty-specific offers, to re-engage dormant customers.

6. Leveraging Data to Optimize Performance

Brands are investing in robust customer data analytics to continuously refine their loyalty strategies. Leading-edge programs use:

• Behavioral Segmentation: Grouping members based on their activity levels and tailoring rewards to drive engagement.
• Predictive Analytics: Anticipating customer needs and preferences to offer proactive incentives.
• Benchmarking Metrics: Regularly comparing program performance against industry standards to identify gaps and opportunities.

By adopting these strategies, growing brands can not only foster loyalty but also turn customers into advocates who champion the brand. As the loyalty landscape evolves, staying ahead requires creativity, agility, and a commitment to understanding your audience at a deeper level.

Baesman Group’s Loyalty Audit provides the foundation for brands looking to achieve this level of success. With a personalized, data-driven approach, we ensure your loyalty strategy is optimized for long-term growth.

We'll work as an extension of your team, meaning we can advise on strategy and design and/or help you implement and conduct longer-term monitoring and optimization strategies to ensure your loyalty program always performs and meets your KPIs. We know growing your DTC brand is of the utmost priority, so we'll advise on strategy and/or are happy to jump in and execute your program as needed.